Friday, February 25, 2011

Trade Deadline Grades

This year's trade deadline saw quite a flurry of deals. I can't remember anything like it in recent years. I guess the closest was '08 with P. Gasol and Bibby being shipped off. Here's a rundown of a number of the trades, as well as our grade for each team involved.

Celtics get Jeff Green, Nenad Krstic, First-round pick
Thunder get Kendrick Perkins, Nate Robinson


Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: D

This trade sucks. It makes me wonder whether Danny Ainge lucked into a championship by finding and taking advantage of a GM (Kevin McHale) that was even dumber than he is. The Celtics decided to address a weakness (backup wing) by creating a larger weakness (post defense and rebounding). The Celtics are now relying on people at the 5 that either can't rebound or defend in the post (Glenn Davis, Nenad Krstic) or can't stay healthy and/or can't play for more than 20 minutes a game (the O'Neals). And for what? So that they could get a guy in Jeff Green who won't play crunch-time minutes and has largely been a disappointment since being drafted fifth. Green is a bad defender and a bad rebounder. He's an okay, but not particularly efficient, scorer. The one thing I am curious to see is whether Green can redesign his game playing at the 3. Since being drafted, he has been forced to play out of position at PF. I was at Georgetown at the same time as Green and have very fond memories of watching him play. During that time, I never saw him as an NBA 4 (or as a top 5 draft pick to be honest). Now that I think about it, I saw him more as a poor man's Paul Pierce. He can pass, shoot, and has a high basketball IQ. But the Celtics already have the real Paul Pierce, they don't need the bootleg version. Also, I keep reading people talk about how the Celtics will now be able to chase D. Howard because of their new cap room in 11-12. That's incorrect; the cap room isn't new. Perkins contract is up after this year, so if the Celtics didn't want to resign him they were already free to do so. This trade does nothing with regard to the Celtics cap situation in a few offseasons. So yeah, to sum it up, Danny Ainge is an idiot.

Gamblers Anonymous: F

This trade makes absolutely no sense. Right when Celtic fans almost forget about Blounts outrageous six years/$42 million contract or Scals five year/$15 million contract Ainge does it again.  The one ring the Celtics did get with this team was built off of toughness and defense, the two biggest qualities Perkins brings to this team. He is regarded as the best 1-1 defending big man in the game. Last year when the Celtics missed out on getting this team their second ring they lost in game 7 to the Lakers due to a lack of rebounding and toughness down low. Gasol and Bynum won that game and really that whole series for the Lakers. Now Ainge has decided to trade the Celtics best, and really only legit center who personifies toughness down low for a back up wing player. It is always good to fill a hole on your bench by making an even bigger one in your starting line up. I have read this trade was done because Perkins was a free agent and was leaving at the end of the year anyway. I hope people realize Green is a restricted free agent who the Thunder were not going to keep anyway and will require big bucks for the Celtics to keep. I have also read this is because C's look at Heat as the real competition and wanted another wing player. This also does not help vs. Heat, their weakness is opposing big men and PGs. The one time Perkins played vs. the Heat this year he had 15 points and controlled the paint the whole time he was in the game. This trade was not done with the future in mind, it was done by a twisted mind that thinks this helps the Celtics now. Dwight Howard is throwing a party right now. I do like Green, but he is not the answer. He is also not a 4. I hope Doc realizes that and does not force him to play out of position like OKC did.


Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: A-

The Thunder finally get the post defender and paint presence that Sam Presti has been searching for since he took the job. He attempted to trade for Tyson Chandler a few years ago, but it fell through when Chandler failed his physical. The Thunder have immensely upgraded themselves on the defensive end. However, this trade does not yet make them legitimate title contenders. Name me a contender that doesn't have a 4 or a 5 that can consistently knock down a mid-range jumper. There are none. Perkins and Serge Ibaka will give teams all kind of trouble on defense, but Perkins has no jumper and while Ibaka's has improved, I still don't think it's good enough. Nick Collison is a good 15 minute guy off the bench, but that's it. There's a reason why Green has been playing out of position for nearly 40 minutes a game over the past few years. So yes, the Thunder have improved, but lets not get carried away.

Gamblers Anonymous: A+

Presti reminds us how he has and will continue to keep a small market team relevant and good while every other one is falling like flies. Green was leaving OKC this off season regardless and he really did not fit in with OKC. He is supposed to be playing the 3 but the hole at 4 is so huge that they had to put someone there to plug it up. The biggest problem the Thunder has had the last two years has been not having any real big man. While I like Ibaka a lot and Collison plays his position, both have flaws and were never cut out to be a starting centers in NBA. Perkins is exactly what they needed. While Perkins will be a free agent too this off-season, now Presti has the inside track to resign him and will be able to offer him the most money. Ibaka and Perkins in the front court look a whole lot more ready to do battle with the Gasols, Bynums, and Duncans, then Kristic and Green. As said above, it is hard to play without one of your 4 or 5s being able to hit a jump shot, but Ibaka's jumper has been steadily improving and I think can provide just enough space in the paint for OKC to win. In a separate trade, the Thunder also got Nazr Mohammed, an expiring contract and a big body, for two players they never use. They are now my pick to win the Western Conference.

Bobcats get Joel Przybilla, Dante Cunningham, Two first-round picks
Blazers get Gerald Wallace


Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: B

They got out of a contract they no longer wanted and, if they can draft well, may get some building blocks.

Gamblers Anonymous: C

If it was any other team I would probably give it a C+, but when looking back at Jordan's draft history I doubt they will use the picks for good use. I also doubt they will be high picks. G Wallace is a beast when healthy and one of the most versatile players in the league, I think they should of gotten better or just hung on to him.


Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: B

The Blazers are capped out anyway, so they may as well try to get some good players. When healthy, Wallace is a borderline All Star. It will be exciting to see him pair with LaMarcus Aldridge. And if Brandon Roy ever gets somewhat-healthy, and if Aldridge can keep playing at his current level with Roy on the floor (two very big ifs), this team could actually be pretty scary.

Gamblers Anonymous: B+

I think I am a little higher on Wallace then my brother. With Camby always out the Blazers need some help on the boards and some versatility. Wallace is just the guy. He legitimately can play the 3 or the 4 and do well at both positions. He will also move Batum into the second unit and will give them more life so they won't have to rely on the streaky and unpredictable Rudy Fernandez. Wallace, Aldridge, Camby is a scary thought when they are all healthy and playing their best.

Nets get Deron Williams
Jazz get Devin Harris, Derrick Favors, Two first-round picks, cash



Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: A-

See my posting below.

Gamblers Anonymous: A-

Agreed. I just wonder if Nets knew the whole they weren't getting Melo and just wanted Nuggets to up the price so the Knicks could gut their whole team.


Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: B

I can't blame the Jazz for sending out Williams if they were confident that he wouldn't resign after next season. They weren't going anywhere this year no matter anyway, so why not maximize Williams' value by trading him now, all while avoiding the drama that Carmelo brought to Denver this year? I think Favors could eventually be a star.



Gamblers Anonymous: B

They got the best they could for him.  Makes you wonder why Sloan left if Deron Williams was getting traded anyway. On a random note, isn't Utah the last place in the world you think of when you hear the word Jazz? [Note from Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: The team was originally the New Orleans Jazz, which makes a lot more sense, and didn't change their name when they moved to Utah.]



Celtics get Second-round pick
Cavaliers get Semih Erden, Luke Harangody



Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: NA

Celtics get an incomplete. We can't assess this deal until we see who Boston brings in to fill the now available roster spots.

Gamblers Anonymous: F

Celtics get a F, again. Why? You could of traded Harongody by himself for a worse pick and kept Erden. Erden is a legit 7 footer who when healthy was great off the bench. Now you go chasing big men who will be bought out right after you just let one go for free. Trade Harongody and Daniels and you still have space for a Sheed and a Troy Murphy. Erden was well deserving of that roster space. He is also young, cheap, and has a future, maybe not as a superstar, but as a good big man off the bench for years to come. Something that is not easy to find.



Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: B+

You probably won't do any better in the second round than Erden and Harangody.

Gamblers Anonymous: A

It wasn't a huge get, but for what they gave up you can't ask for more.


Celtics get Second-round pick
Kings get Marquis Daniels

Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: NA

Celtics get an incomplete. See above.

Gamblers Anonymous: A

Why not do it? He wasn't coming back and it opens up a roster space.



Kings get a....whatever. They only did this deal because they were under the mandated salary basement. This team needs new ownership.

Knicks get Carmelo Anthony, Chauncey Billups, Shelden Williams, Renaldo Balkman, Anthony Carter, Corey Brewer
Nuggets get Danilo Gallinari, Wilson Chandler, Raymond Felton, Timofey Mozgov, Kosta Koufos, First-round pick, Two second-round picks
Timberwolves get Eddy Curry, Anthony Randolph


Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: B-

Honestly, this trade leaves the Knicks in pretty much the same situation they were already in . Either way, they were set to be a playoff team for a few years, but not a contender. The only real positive is that--if the salary cap allows for it--Carmelo's presence may help lure a star in a few years. Other than that, despite all the noise, they really didn't get much better.

Gamblers Anonymous: B

I wrote about it below. Hard to grade this one until we see what happens and who else this brings.




Gamblers Anonymous' Brother: B+

The Nuggets really did pretty well for themselves considering that everyone knew they had to get rid of Carmelo. Yes, they would have preferred the Nets offer, but they still got some bona fide NBA talent. That's better than a lot of other teams have done in the past when shipping out a star (See: Philadelphia trading Iverson, Minnesota trading Garnett, Memphis trading P. Gasol, etc.).

Gamblers Anonymous: A-

Looks like all the waiting they did paid off. George Karl has never looked happier and they got back real talent, something that is rare when trading a disgruntle superstar.




Timberwolves get a C. By law, any move that David Kahn makes cannot receive a higher grade than a C. The Timberwolves continue their habit of helping others make deals by serving as an unimportant third team. The chatter about Randolph just needing to get away from Don Nelson has gone silent.


Rockets get Suns future 1st round pick, Goran Dragic, Hasheem Thabeet, and Memphis future 1st round pick. They give up Aaron Brooks, Shane Battier, and Ish Smith.

Gamblers Anonymous: A

I am not going to go over the other sides of these trades or these trades individually, but Rockets get an A. They traded away Brooks, who was not working out in Houston and looked like he was never getting his starting role back from Lowry. Battier is 32 years old and was leaving this off season anyway. Ish Smith.. Who? In return they got Thabeet, a 7'3 2nd pick in 2009 draft. He has been a disappointment so far, but is well worth the gamble, and with what they traded away its not much of a gamble at all. Dragic took a step back this year but has showed promise last year and is a bigger body then Aaron Brooks. They also received two future 1st rounds picks from teams that I don't think will be winning any time soon. How can they lose with this one?

0 comments:

Post a Comment